BASIC MANAGEMENT BOOK FOR ISKCON TEMPLES
Presented for the GBC by Srila Harikesa Swami Visnupada
Table of Contents
Introduction
1. What is a
Temple?
1.1 The Temple
1.2 A Preaching
Center
1.3 A Nama-hatta
Center
1.4 An ISKCON Center
2. Basic ISKCON
Management Structure
2.1 The Temple
President
2.2 The
Department Heads
3. General
Guidelines for a Good Manager
3.1 Srila
Prabhupada's Unique position in ISKCON
3.2 The Best
Manager is the Best Preacher
3.3 Satisfaction
of the Spiritual Master
3.4 Sadhana
3.5 Advance
Notification
3.6 Honesty
3.7 Caring
3.8 Dealing with
the GBC
3.9 Group
Efforts
3.10
Considerations of the Asrama of a Manager
4. Pitfalls in
Daily Management
4.1 Expansion
Beyond One's Means
4.2 The
Paraphernalia Trap
4.3 Lust, Anger
and Greed
4.4 Boredom
5. A Brief
Description of the Relevance of Varnasrama in ISKCON
5.1 Engaging
Devotees According to their Propensities
5.2 The Role of
Brahmanas in the Temple
6. The Temple
Spiritual Program and Spiritual Standards
6.1 The Temple
Programs
6.2 Training
Programs for Devotees
6.3 Engagement
of Others in Devotional Service
6.4 Deity
Worship
6.5 Standards for
Worship of Gaura-Nitai
6.6 Temple
Preaching Programs
7. Temple
Maintenance
8. Preaching
8.1 Book
Production and Distribution
8.2 Hari-nama
Chanting Parties and Prasada Distribution
8.3 Festivals
8.4
Institutional Preaching
8.5 Programs
Arranged by Other Organizations
8.6
Congregational Preaching
8.7 Bhakta
Program
8.8 Guest
Reception
9. Vehicles
10. Devotees
Health and Welfare
11. Cleanliness
12. The Sunday
Feast
13. The Kitchen
13.1 Standards of
Cleanliness
13.2 Purchasing
Foods, Storage, and Garbage Disposal
13.3 Recipes
13.4 Management
of Cooking
14. Prasada
Serving
15. India
Festivals and Other Communication to the Outside World
16. Management
and Administration
17. Bookkeeping
and Accounting
18. Legal
Affairs
19. Public
Relations
20. Asrama Life
20.1 Celibate
Life
20.2 Grhastha
Life
21. Problem
Solving
22. ISKCON Farm
Communities
Introduction
Management is an art. To properly manage a
temple requires skills.
These skills have to be learned before a temple may be
properly managed.
Sometimes these skills are learned in the school of hard
knocks, where hit
or miss management gradually trains the temple president
to understand
what can be done and what should be avoided. But such
schooling takes
time, energy, and unfortunately costs a lot of money as
wastage is high. A
superior form of training is to learn from those who have
already gone
through enough schooling to understand what is the actual
standard of
temple management.
This book is
meant to be a manual for training new temple authorities
in their duties. It will not be the comprehensive and
final edition on the
subject, but rather a beginner's guide to ISKCON
management. Those who
systematically go through this book will get enough
information to learn
how to manage a temple even if they are complete
managerial neophytes. Of
course, a prospective candidate for the position of
temple president must
have certain prerequisite qualifications to manage. This
book cannot grant
one those qualifications if one does not have them, but
it can help one
who is basically qualified to learn.
As the preaching
expands the number of centers in the world increase
and the need for training temple presidents and other
temple officers also
increases. Originally this manual was written for the
Soviet Union as
there were many temples rapidly developing without proper
leadership.
Later on it was adapted for usage by ISKCON around the
world. This book
cannot be complete, for situations can arise which we
cannot now foresee.
The purpose of
this book is to create a course of management. It is
meant to educate neophytes into the basic principles of
temple management,
as they were understood from Srila Prabhupada and
developed over the years
in ISKCON. This book might also serve to help even an
experienced manager
see something which he missed over the years. In any case
it is meant to
help one successfully manage an ISKCON temple in most of
its aspects.
Our simple
advice is: read this book from cover to cover, then go back
over the sections which you require to immediately
improve and study them
in great detail. Make the required changes in the temple
you manage, and
then move on to the next section and repeat the process
until the temple
is fairly well organized. If you have a hard time
understanding some
portion of the book, then address the questions to your
local GBC who will
most likely satisfy you.
I wish you the
blessings of the Supreme Lord Sri Krishna in your attempt
to increase your management skills, and pray that this
work will both
satisfy the Lord and accomplish its goals.
Harikesa Swami
Mayapur March 25, 1991
1. What is a Temple?
Since this book
is about temple management, the first thing that we
should understand is, what is a temple? There are various
forms of
preaching units in ISKCON. There are large temples, small
temples,
preaching centers, nama-hatta centers, and even
householder flats.
Although each of these units is somewhat different in its
structure, we
will not make much distinction between these centers
while writing this
book. We will simply speak about temple management
understanding that
basically the same principles will apply in all cases. It
is up to the
temple authority to adjust the principles for his own
particular instance.
Later, we shall discuss these different preaching units
in greater detail
to distinguish one from the other where the differences
require specific
explanation.
1.1 The Temple
A temple is an
ISKCON center of preaching activities wherein devotees
gather together to worship the Supreme Lord Sri Krishna
under the
direction of the Founder-Acarya of ISKCON, His Divine
Grace A.C.
Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada. The devotees all follow
the four
regulative principles, chant 16 rounds of the Hare
Krishna mantra on beads
each day, and follow all the regulated temple programs. A
temple will
usually have Deities of the Lord in a temple room wherein
kirtana and
classes are held. A temple will have temple officers, at
least a
president, and treasurer, and sometimes also a secretary,
temple
commander, and department heads such as a sankirtana
leader, head pujari,
head cook and so on.
Sunday feasts,
school programs, devotee making and training, and a
regulated temple program of kirtanas, classes and prasada
are some basic
elements of temple life. Asramas for sannyasis,
brahmacaris and
brahmacarinis as well as certain qualified householders,
are available for
the devotees. Books are directly purchased from the BBT
and sold on
sankirtana and through the temple bookstores.
In short, a
temple is a place where Krishna is worshiped and devotees
live and are trained, with the goal of preaching Krishna
consciousness
throughout the area.
1.2 A Preaching Center
A preaching
center is like a temple, but it is of a smaller size and
stature. A preaching center may be manned by one or two
initiated devotees
who are trying to preach Krishna consciousness in the
area. The center
will perform basically the same functions as the temple,
but without
elaborate Deity worship and other larger programs. It is
a small unit
meant for preaching whose goal is to gradually grow into
a full scale
temple with all forms of worship and training of new
devotees.
1.3 A Nama-hatta Center
A nama-hatta
center is different from a preaching center or a temple in
that there are initially no initiated devotees, regulated
temple programs
or expanded preaching. This kind of a center is a place
where interested
people, most of whom do not chant 16 rounds a day or even
follow all the
regulated principles, may gather together and
occasionally chant kirtana
or hold programs when travelling preachers come by. Later
on, some members
of the nama-hatta may come to the standard of being full
time devotees and
get initiated wherein the status of the center may change
to that of a
preaching center.
1.4 An ISKCON Center
All temples,
preaching centers, nama-hatta centers, restaurants, shops
and so on, must be recognized by ISKCON before they may
use the trade
marked names of ISKCON such as "ISKCON",
"The Hare Krishna Movement",
"Govindas", and so on.
A unit may be a
part of ISKCON if it:
* Recognizes that His Divine Grace A.C. Bhaktivedanta
Swami Prabhupada is
the Founder-Acarya of ISKCON and that the instructions
found in his books
and other works form the basis of all direction in ISKCON
and that they
follow these instructions.
* Recognizes that the Governing Body Commission is the
ultimate managing
authority for ISKCON and that the constitution of ISKCON
is the guiding
authority for the structure of the movement.
* Works under the authority of the designated GBC
representatives in the
region.
There are a few
other important items which every ISKCON center must
follow. Every temple that owns property must have three
property trustees
recognized by the GBC Executors Committee to insure that
the property
cannot be sold or mortgaged without the approval of these
trustees.
Further, each temple president must sign an Oath of
Allegiance to ISKCON
and this must be on file with the local GBC secretary. In
addition, each
temple must pay yearly fees to the GBC Communications
Office for services
provided by the GBC and must also pay a fee for the
ISKCON Board of
Education. Later, each temple will be licensed to use the
name ISKCON and
be a recognized part of the society. In this way, by
following all the
above items, one gets official recognition as a part of
ISKCON.
2. Basic ISKCON Management Structure
ISKCON has a
basic structure which must be understood and maintained in
all respects. If a temple or other unit disregards this
basic structure,
they cannot expect to remain a part of ISKCON for long.
Therefore a clear
idea of what is ISKCON and what is its structure is
essential for proper
temple management.
First of all,
the instructions of Srila Prabhupada form the basis for
all aspects of temple life. His words and directions hold
the society
together and keep it in the same basic direction. In the
early 1970's,
Srila Prabhupada created a basic direction of management
wherein he
created the Governing Body Commission of ISKCON. This
Commission, known as
the GBC, was meant to take over the burden of management
from Srila
Prabhupada during his lifetime, and, after his departure,
to manage all
the affairs of ISKCON. In Prabhupada's final will, he
stated that: "The
Governing Body Commission shall be the ultimate managing
authority for all
affairs of the International Society for Krishna
Consciousness." Thus the
GBC today functions as the ultimate managing authority
for all activities
in ISKCON.
The GBC body
meets at least once a year in Mayapur at its annual
meeting. During this meeting resolutions are passed
giving direction to
the society. Part of these resolutions deal with
designating GBC
representatives for the different areas of the ISKCON
world. These
officially designated GBC secretaries then act as the
representatives of
the entire GBC body in their specific zones. For the
devotees in their
zone, they act as the highest authority in terms of the
spiritual
management. They are responsible to the GBC body for the
spiritual
standards of the temples and devotees in their zone.
To efficiently
deal with the management requirements within a smaller
geographical area, some GBC men have created Regional
Councils wherein the
temple presidents and senior preachers within a specified
region meet
together regularly to cooperatively make sure that the
temples are
maintaining their standards and that preaching is going
on in a
coordinated manner. They can also expand their duties as
they desire to
manage things more properly. Other GBC members have
instituted the system
of regional secretaries who assist the GBC in the
performance of his
regional duties.
The next stage
of ISKCON management is the temples. The temple is the
basic unit of ISKCON's structure. These temples are meant
to be self
sufficient preaching units where devotees may live and
prosper. Within
each temple there is a temple president, and usually a
treasurer. There
may also be a secretary and other temple authorities. The
authority
structure in the temple descends from the temple
president to the temple
commander and then through the department heads such as
the head pujari,
head cook, sankirtana leader and so on. Sometimes the
temple commander is
considered as a department head. These department heads
are responsible
for all the activities within their department.
Since the temple
is the basic unit of management in ISKCON, it is
important to know the specific duties of the temple
officers and
department heads.
2.1 The Temple President
The Temple
President is directly responsible for all the affairs of the
temple. He may be of two types. The first type is a
brahminical leader who
works through a temple commander of the ksatriya nature,
or he may be a
ksatriya leader who allows the brahmanas of the temple to
lead the temple
spiritually. Either role model can work if the
relationships are seen in
terms of the varnasrama-dharma system.
The brahminical
type of temple president is one who manages mainly
through preaching and giving a good spiritual example to
the other
devotees. He gives good classes and inspires the devotees
to serve Krishna
and thus easily gets the devotees in the temple working
for Krishna out of
their own voluntary desire. He doesn't have to force
anyone to do anything
since they do everything out of their own spiritual
desire being convinced
by his preaching.
This type of
president manages the temple through the temple commander
and the department heads. He instructs the temple
commander and department
heads to accomplish certain goals and they execute these
goals by making
plans and carrying them out. In this way all management
is done by others
and the brahminical temple president sees that their
goals are Krishna
conscious and met.
The second type
of temple president is himself a great manager and
leader of men. He will work intimately with all the
members of the
community and directly manage their activities. He may
also have a temple
commander and department heads, but he is managing their
affairs in a very
"hands on" manner through active participation
and direct intervention.
This ksatriya
type of temple president will depend on his brahmanas or
sannyasis in the community to do the bulk of the
preaching and spiritual
leadership. He will give them all facilities to preach
and present Krishna
consciousness in the temple. The temple runs through
their spiritual
example and power. He depends on these brahmanas, and may
even have a
brahminical council to give him occasional direction,
when it is required,
for problems which are too difficult for him to solve
personally.
Both types of
temple presidents should understand that their basic mood
is to serve their spiritual master, the Deity, and the
devotees. This
service attitude is very important. The more the
president thinks of
himself as the servant of the devotees the better the
management will be.
When a president thinks himself the servant of the
devotees then it is
easy for him to engage the devotees in service, for this
is his service to
them. He knows that a devotee cannot be happy unless he
is nicely engaged
in devotional service. He will also want to please the
devotees by
supplying their basic needs for their maintenance and
preaching. Such a
president is loved by the devotees and will always
succeed, whereas one
who thinks himself the master of the devotees will always
run into
difficulties and conflict with others who are not fully
surrendered souls.
2.2 The Department Heads
The department
heads are responsible for their particular department's
activities. For example, the sankirtana leader is
responsible to see that
all the devotees engaged in sankirtana are going out each
day; are getting
good spots; are paying for their books; are following the
temple programs
for spiritual strength; are getting proper clothes
appropriate for the
weather; are getting good prasada for bodily health; are
getting medicine
when sick, and so on. In other words, he is responsible
for their daily
needs and requirements. He must carefully manage the
department to make
sure that every one of the devotees dependent on him is
happily engaged in
their service. At the same time he must act as a liaison
with the temple
president to inform him of the activities and results of
the department
and get further input, funding and manpower to accomplish
his goals.
In the example
of sankirtana, there are also group leaders. This
principle exists in other departments as well when the
department is large
and spread out over a wide area. A group leader
represents the authority
of the department head and will basically take care of
the same things as
the department head but on a smaller scale.
3. General Guidelines for a Good Manager
In this chapter
we will speak in a general way about certain principles
which will help any temple manager regardless of his
particular position.
These principles are essential for success in managing an
ISKCON temple.
3.1 Srila Prabhupada's Unique position in ISKCON
The first and
foremost principle is the recognition of Srila
Prabhupada's position as the Founder-Acarya of ISKCON.
Being the
Founder-Acarya is no ordinary position. Others may act as
spiritual
masters within ISKCON, but only one person and no other,
may hold the
position of Founder-Acarya. Founder-Acarya means that
this individual has
created a society which is a significant branch of the
Caitanya tree.
Srila Prabhupada has created a society which was so
significant that it
spread all over the world within a very short period of
time. No one else
ever performed such a preaching work and therefore he is
glorified as the
Founder-Acarya of ISKCON, and indeed, the whole world.
Because
Prabhupada has such a unique position, his teachings and
writings form a unique body of knowledge which will guide
and direct the
activities of all the devotees of ISKCON for at least the
next 10,000
years when Krishna consciousness is flourishing on this
planet. Therefore
all temple managers must read and study the books of
Srila Prabhupada in
order to clearly understand the basic standards of
ISKCON. Every temple
leader must read regularly the books of Srila Prabhupada
in order to know
the philosophy. Without knowing the philosophy of Krishna
consciousness no
one can preach. And, as the next point will show, without
preaching, there
is no real management in this spiritual movement.
3.2 The Best Manager is the Best Preacher
Srila Prabhupada
once told me: "The best manager is the best preacher."
What he meant by that is simple. If one preaches to the
devotees in the
temple in a nice way, they will develop a service
attitude and want to
render service to the Lord and the spiritual master. They
will be properly
motivated without the requirement of some extra special
endeavor.
Therefore it is incumbent on every temple president to
carefully and
enthusiastically preach to the devotees at every
opportunity. The better
he preaches, the more the devotees will respect him and
then naturally
want to serve under his instruction.
Srila Prabhupada
wanted his temple leaders to always think of newer
ways to inspire the devotees. Therefore the temple
presidents, in
conjunction with the GBC, should think up newer and newer
projects which
will inspire the devotees. Of course, the sankirtana
mission requires that
the temple remain fixed in book distribution, but the
president can set
goals such as increasing the number of devotees and then
training them to
go out on sankirtana. This will certainly inspire the
devotees. Further,
he can create a number of marathons during the year which
will inspire the
devotees before special festival days. There are other
programs which will
enthuse the devotees, such as the observance of large
festivals in the
cities. In this way he should think of ways and means to
inspire the
devotees.
The nice thing
about the preaching manager is that he never orders
others on his own account. He never says: "I am
saying this and therefore
you should follow me!"; rather, he simply represents
the will and desire
of the previous acaryas who have already given us the
orders of what to do
to spread the mission of Krishna consciousness. Because
he is a
representative of the previous acaryas, he will be loved
by the devotees
and the devotees will also love to follow his
instructions because they
can see that these instructions are not motivated by
personal desires for
name and fame, but are motivated by the pure desire to simply
serve the
previous acaryas. There is a wealth of difference between
a devotee who
orders others to satisfy his personal whim as compared to
one who wishes
to satisfy the spiritual master. This brings us to the
next point.
3.3 Satisfaction of the Spiritual Master
The most
essential principle that operates in spiritual life is total
dedication of one's life, wealth, words, and intelligence
in the mission
of one's spiritual master. Dedication to the mission of
the spiritual
master is the perfection that fulfills all desires. If
one wants to have
success in spiritual life, the secret is to fully
dedicate himself to
following the instructions and fulfilling the mission of
the spiritual
master. No other principle in spiritual life works as
effectively in
developing all spiritual success.
We should all
understand that the mission received in ISKCON descends
from the original mission presented by Srila Prabhupada
and therefore the
mission of all future spiritual masters must be in accordance
with the
mission of Srila Prabhupada. If one acting as a spiritual
master deviates
from the mission of Srila Prabhupada then he becomes
asara, or useless.
Prabhupada had many goals for this ISKCON movement, but
all of these goals
were to be accomplished through preaching. Simply by
increasing the
preaching, of which book distribution is the most
important part, one can
automatically fulfill all the other goals within the
society. Therefore we
stress so much on book distribution and preaching since
it is the life of
ISKCON and the source of all success in spiritual life.
When the book
distribution and preaching is going on nicely, then all
the other aspects
of spiritual life will also go on nicely with the minimum
of management.
This is not only a theory of good management but it has
been practically
seen in temples where this principle is sincerely
followed.
3.4 Sadhana
Every temple
authority, and indeed, every devotee within ISKCON, should
strictly maintain their standards of sadhana-bhakti.
Sadhana means the
regulative principles of devotional service. Every temple
authority must
always rise early in the morning, take his bath, put on
clean cloth and
then come to the temple for the full morning program. If
he does that, he
will personally be Krishna conscious throughout the day,
and he will be
able to properly lead the devotees in their own spiritual
sadhana-bhakti.
One who does not properly follow sadhana will have a hard
time convincing
others to do so. This sadhana forms the basis of
spiritual life upon which
all spiritual perfection will grow.
Sometimes a
temple president will not follow the temple program using
his heavy work load as an excuse. But working all day
without following
the temple program is activity in the mode of passion and
will not
increase the management efficiency in the long run.
Actually, it will
decrease the effectiveness of the management for without
spiritual
strength no one can go on taking up heavy managerial
responsibility for
long. Therefore the temple presidents must be sure to
follow the temple
programs strictly. They should properly chant their 16
rounds of the Hare
Krishna maha-mantra each day and carefully hear the
mantra. This will give
them the spiritual strength to go on with their
managerial duties.
Although the
temple president must be strict in his following of the
sadhana process, he will still be faced with various
emergency services
throughout the day. Sometimes these emergencies will
arise during the
morning program and he will have to deal with them. If
someone approaches
him with a problem during the japa time, for example, he
should politely
direct that person to another temple authority who can
deal with the
situation, or he should propose a means by which the
problem may be solved
without his having to become personally entangled in it.
He should not
become angry at the person approaching him and deal with
the situation as
far as required. Sometimes the situation is so serious
that it demands his
immediate attention. He should then surrender to Krishna
and take care of
the situation as quickly as possible. However, if he is
approached with a
routine matter during his japa or the morning program, he
should declare
that the matter can be taken care of later on during the
normal working
hours and that now is the time for chanting and hearing.
He should strive
to keep his sadhana intact despite occasional
disruptions.
3.5 Advance Notification
Devotees don't
like to be surprised with unexpected services. This is
natural. They like to know what they have to do before
they have to
actually do it so they can arrange their lives in such a
way as to best
accomplish the tasks before them. Knowing this, a wise
temple president
will assist the devotees by notifying them well in
advance what their
devotional service will be in the future.
For example, if
there is going to be a special kirtana party on the
streets on Saturday, the temple president should notify
the devotees on
Monday of the planned kirtana. He should also repeat it
on Wednesday and
again on Friday. In this way all the devotees will know
that on Saturday
they will be expected to come to the kirtana and they
will plan
accordingly. The temple president who gives advance notification
will
minimize the possibility that he will hear from the
devotees: "I can't go,
I have other things to do."
If the temple
president is planning a sankirtana marathon, let us say
in the month of December (the traditional time for an ISKCON
marathon), he
should start informing everyone of the marathon in
October. He should
mention it a few times until everyone is informed that in
December there
is going to be a marathon and everyone should take part
in it. His
preaching about the marathon should increase in November
to expand the
sankirtana fever so that by the end of November the
marathon is in the
front of everyone's consciousness. There should be no
surprises or the
sudden introduction of a new activity on the devotees for
this will be
counterproductive.
This is also
true for smaller things such as a cleaning marathon in the
temple. If there is to be a cleaning marathon on Friday,
for example, then
it should be announced on Monday so everyone can prepare
their schedules
to accommodate it. This is important for the smooth
management of the
temple.
3.6 Honesty
A temple
president must be honest with the devotees. If he makes a
statement to the devotees, he should back it up with
action. For example,
if he states, "If you work nicely in your department
all year long, then I
will send you to Mayapur for the festival", then he
should actually carry
out that promise. If he does not, he will risk losing all
the faith of
that devotee and others as well. Certainly the devotee
who has been
promised will speak with others and this will cause a
general diminishing
of the faith of the devotees in the temple president. So
when the temple
president makes a promise to the devotees, he should
fulfill it, even if
it is hard to do so. His credibility as a leader to be
trusted and
believed depends on it.
Besides, the
golden rule in the material world is: "Do unto others as
you would have them do unto you." If someone made a
promise to us and then
broke it, we would not like it at all. Commonly a
president might think:
"We are all devotees, so the others should just
understand that I cannot
fulfill my promise and accept it as Krishna's
mercy." But this is a lot to
expect from neophyte devotees. In fact, one should not
even expect it from
advanced devotees. To mislead a devotee to whom a promise
was made is a
very bad thing and is against the etiquette of vaisnavas.
If one keeps his
word he will become known as a person who can be trusted.
This is an
essential quality for a successful temple president.
There are
occasions when a promise simply cannot be fulfilled, and such
circumstances teach us what to say when we promise
something. For example,
if a devotee was promised that he could go to Mayapur for
the festival,
yet the temple is completely broke at the time of
departure, or the price
of the air fare has increased enormously, then it might
be that the
promise cannot be fulfilled. Of course, the new situation
can be explained
to the expectant devotee and perhaps he will accept that,
but it is a
risk. Therefore it is better not to make promises that
might not be
fulfilled later on. One might say something like: "I
can't guarantee
anything, but we can try and arrange it if all goes
well." Such statements
do not constitute a promise yet give hope to the devotee
who has a desire
to fulfil. Sometimes one can confidently state something
more specific if
he is sure that it can be fulfilled.
3.7 Caring
A good temple
president always thinks about the welfare of the
devotees. He will make sure that they are well taken care
of at all times.
He is concerned that they have a proper place to rest,
that it is peaceful
and well heated, as well as comfortable. He should make
sure that the
residence of the devotees is as nice as his own.
The ideal
president is a perfect host for visiting devotees. He should
always make sure that a new guest in the temple has been
given prasada, a
nice place to stay, as well as whatever things he needs
to be comfortable.
Of course, this means within reason, but if one just
greets a new guest
with sweet words and the basic facilities needed for
devotional life, he
will satisfy that guest and get his blessings. A
president who cares for
his guests will find that more and more guests will come
to the temple.
This is very important when one wants to attract senior
devotees to come
to the temple and preach. They remember more than
anything else the
reception they are given, and the word will spread,
either good or bad.
Nothing ruins a temple more than the reputation that one
will not be
treated properly there. If such a reputation gets out,
then it will be
very hard to attract travelling preachers to come and
stay for some time.
Therefore one should always endeavor to be a perfect host
to attract more
and more travelling preachers to the temple.
One may ask what
is the use of having travelling preachers come to the
temple? But it is seen in those places where senior
devotees come and
preach that the devotees are always enlivened and happy.
Whenever a new
person comes and preaches it is a kind of mini festival
and the devotees
feel satisfied that someone new is there to give the
classes and lead some
kirtanas. After all, variety is the spice of life. The
realizations of the
new preachers keep the atmosphere from getting stale and
keep everyone
enlivened.
One of the most
important features in caring for devotees is to make
sure that the prasada is always good, on time, clean, and
hot. If prasada
is nice, and well served (see the section on serving
prasada) then the
devotees will always feel satisfied and they will be
enthusiastic to
perform their services. Srila Prabhupada once
spontaneously wrote me a
letter thanking me for the nice prasada that I was
serving the devotees in
the temple. He considered this as most important for the
spiritual lives
of the devotees.
If a guest comes
to the temple, he should be always greeted with some
nice prasada. This will satisfy anyone who has come from
a long distance.
Srila Prabhupada also said that anyone who comes to the
temple, at any
time of the day, should be offered some prasada. Some
sabji can be always
available, and some puris can be quickly prepared from
puri dough ready in
the refrigerator and ghi in the pan quickly heated up. A
sweet should be
available and this will satisfy any gentleman.
An important
part of caring for the devotees is giving them proper
medical care. If they are sick, it is essential that
someone take care of
them. Giving them water, or fruit juice, if that will
help them in their
particular sickness, as well as bringing a doctor if
required and
supplying them medicine, will go a long way to both
helping the devotees
in their time of crisis, and also endearing them to the
management. If the
managers care for the devotees when they are sick or
injured, the devotees
tend to become very grateful, as any person would be, and
then they will
increase their service when they get better.
It is only common
sense to take care of the devotees when they are
sick. It is a kind of reciprocation. When they are well,
they are working
hard for the temple, and when they are sick, the temple
takes care of
them. Often we hear of devotees who were just left
neglected somewhere
during some illness. They often become bitter and want to
leave that place
as soon as they can. This is certainly a good way to lose
devotees. By
simply taking care of them, they can expand their service
to Krishna and
their spiritual master more and more. This is also true
of a devotee who
is not a devotee of your temple. If a guest is sick, one
should treat him
with all the facilities of a temple devotee for the guest
is helpless and
dependent on the temple at that stage. Someday you will
be in another
temple, and you may also fall sick.
Sometimes temple
managers are extremely austere. When they fall sick
they do not feel that any special attention is required
and they just go
on serving despite their illness. This is not good from
two points of
view. The first point is that when one is sick and does
not take care of
himself he tends to get sicker or the disease becomes
chronic and cannot
be easily cured later on. This causes a disturbance in
his service. Do not
neglect the body thinking it to be merely maya. One
should rather see the
body as a temple of God and carefully take care of this
valuable tool for
self realization. It is our responsibility to take care
of the body and
keep it healthy. The second point is that when one
neglects his own bodily
illness he tends to become callous to the illness of
others. He thinks: "I
would not care if this were happening to me, so why
should we waste time
trying to cure others?" This attitude is impersonal
and will create many
troubles for the devotees in the temple. One should take
care of himself
and others as well.
It must be noted
here that sometimes devotees become overly concerned
with their bodies. Although we must take care of the
body, we also know
that the bodily problems we face are a product of our
past sinful actions
and there is sometimes not much we can do about it. If,
after repeated
attempts to cure ourselves, we find that it is impossible
or extremely
difficult, we should give up the endeavor and simply
depend on the mercy
of the Supreme Personality of Godhead who can reduce the
heavy burden of
our karma if He so desires. Knowing how far to endeavor
to take care of
the body is a difficult subject requiring a lot of
maturity. If the temple
president possesses that maturity he can nicely take care
of the devotees
in the temple according to their actual needs. Such
maturity can only be
gained over time, but it should be the goal of all temple
managers.
3.8 Dealing with the GBC
The GBC of the
local area is the appointed representative of the entire
Governing Body Commission of ISKCON and is thus the
representative of
Srila Prabhupada's will. Therefore he should be well
taken care of. He
should have a proper room, proper prasada, and also someone
to take care
of his needs such as washing of clothes and bedding.
Besides the
normal bodily maintenance of the GBC member, there is also
the relationship of managerial cooperation that must be
maintained. The
GBC member is there to help the president do his job
better. He is meant
to train the president if there is some lacking on his
part, and to help
him make the decisions which are essential to success in
management.
Therefore one should be open and friendly with him. It is
not the time to
be closed up and unfriendly when the GBC member is
coming. If one deals
with his GBC member with hostility, this is
counterproductive to the
Krishna conscious ideal of vaisnava humility and
etiquette. Usually the
GBC member is very senior and therefore he should be
respected by the
temple authorities.
If there are
problems, for example if the GBC member asks the temple
president to do something he doesn't want to do, then
they should discuss
the situation together and come to some mutually acceptable
conclusion. If
there are very serious problems, then perhaps another GBC
member can be
called in to help mediate the situation and come to some
conclusion. But
one should never openly fight with the GBC member or
criticize him to the
general devotees. This would be the worst thing to do
since it will cause
irreparable damage to the faith of the devotees. Srila
Prabhupada wanted
that the GBC and temple presidents work together in close
harmony for the
overall benefit of ISKCON and it is up to the temple
president to fulfill
his part of the bargain by fully cooperating with the GBC
member as far as
possible.
The GBC member
will correct any mistakes or deviations created by the
temple managers. This is part of their job. If the GBC secretaries,
who
are capable of seeing what is right and wrong, see
something improper in
the temple, they will usually correct it as soon as
possible. Of course
there may be many things wrong in the temple, especially
in these
beginning stages of management, and the GBC
representative may not choose
to correct all these things at once. He will bring the
temple up to the
proper standard over time. The temple managers should
appreciate that they
have a guide to follow who will understand their needs
and problems and
give good instruction where it is needed.
Later on, when
the management is running more smoothly and up to the
proper standard of spiritual life, the GBC representative
may take a more
advisory role and give instruction in a more brahminical
fashion. The GBC
secretaries are actually meant to guide the presidents by
giving them good
advice and direction where it is needed. They can also
help the presidents
make good decisions. Naturally the GBC will want to
assist the temple
presidents to expand the movement more and more.
Therefore the presidents
should cooperate with the GBC secretaries in all ways.
3.9 Group Efforts
There are two
basic ways in which something can be managed. One may
take all the responsibility on his own shoulders and
singularly manage
something, or he may create a group to discuss and plan
out the course of
action to be executed. Sometimes it is seemingly more
efficient to do
things alone, for having to deal with many others on
managerial affairs is
a difficult thing to do. But in the long run it is not
really recommended.
If we make decisions which are wrong, or at least not
appreciated by the
others in the temple, then the responsibility for those
improper decisions
rests solely and wholely on our own shoulders. This can
become quite
unpleasant and can cause one to become very discouraged.
Therefore, making
larger decisions which give overall direction to the
temple are better
made in small groups specifically designed to make such
decisions. The
decision made by the group is usually a better one, as
the subject being
decided would be considered from many different
perspectives. And it is a
fact that those who participate in making the decision
are naturally more
inspired to work to implement it. When all the managers
in the temple are
moving in the same direction the management becomes quite
easy and
powerful. But if individual managers have different ideas
then there is
conflict and everyone's energy is wasted. Therefore group
decisions are
more conducive to successful management.
3.10 Considerations of the Asrama of a Manager
A temple
president usually has to deal with women. Formerly in ISKCON
this was resolved by having all the temple presidents
marry. Although this
helps solve the problem to some degree, it is not a final
solution.
Dealing with women is a difficult thing for a man and
this sometimes will
preclude brahmacaris and sannyasis from managing temples.
Still, one will
see brahmacaris and sannyasis running a temple now and
then. It is
difficult, but it can be done if one is very expert and
detached.
There is nothing
wrong with a householder managing a temple so long as
he does not utilize the facilities of the temple for his
own personal
sense gratification. Certainly the president may get his
basic
requirements for living and eating fulfilled through the
temple, and he
may also have his own place to live outside. However, he
should not
exploit the temple for his own sense gratification, for
that would be
taking more than his quota. The œsopanisad warns us that
everything is
owned and controlled by the Lord and therefore one should
not take more
than that which is allotted to him by the will of the
Lord. A temple
president must be careful not to take more than what
would be allotted to
any other householder who is working full time for the
temple. For
example, he should not have specially prepared opulent
meals when the
temple devotees are eating austerely. In fact he should
eat with the
devotees. Neither should he use temple funds to buy
himself a nice vehicle
while the other devotees are walking or taking the bus.
He should take
what is needed to expand his service, but not for
expanding his sense
gratification. This subject will be discussed in more
detail later on in
the book.
Whether one is
married or not, one must deal with married and unmarried
women. It is dangerous to deal with women since there is
always the chance
that one may become attached and thus entangled with some
other lady. We
have seen in the past temple presidents fall down because
of having to
deal with women. Brahmacari managers have gotten
themselves married due to
attachment to one of the girls in the temple and
householder managers have
fallen down with another man's wife and run away from
their position.
Sometimes illicit sex can take place when no one is
looking and this
causes the destruction of that devotee's spiritual life.
If the president
gets entangled in this manner the temple can become
destroyed, so one must
avoid such entanglements by all means. Some hints are as
follows. If he is
dealing with unmarried ladies, then the oldest, and
hopefully the most
capable, among them should try to take care of the girls.
If the ladies
are married, then the temple president should engage the
ladies either
through the husband of the lady, or he should have his
wife engage the
lady directly. This will avoid the unsavory situation of
the temple
president having to intimately deal with someone else's
wife. Being the
wife of a temple president has its responsibilities for
the wife of the
temple president must act as his representative in
dealing with the other
ladies in the temple.
Sometimes the
wife of the temple president does not want to, or cannot,
deal with the management of the other ladies in the
temple. If this
happens then the temple president has no choice but to do
it himself. This
is not so bad if he is just giving simple instructions to
the ladies for
their service, but if they have more mental problems, as
ladies often do,
then it will become more difficult. The wife of the
temple president may
then act as a messenger between the ladies with the
problems and her
husband, carrying good instructions to them with the
hopes that this will
satisfy them. If they still require more attention, then
the wife of the
temple president may sit with her husband while he speaks
with the lady
with a problem.
If the problem
that is discussed is one of a marital nature; that is, a
problem between husband and wife, the temple president
should recommend
that the couple work out their problems amongst
themselves. He might also
recommend that the problem be brought up to their
spiritual master for his
opinion. It is important that married couples work out
their interpersonal
problems as best they can amongst themselves, for it is
extremely
difficult for anyone else to do it for them.
If the temple
president is dealing with someone else's wife through her
husband, and the husband is in maya to some serious
degree, then the
temple president will have no choice but to deal with the
wife directly.
But this must be done in a most discreet manner.
Sometimes it has been
seen that a temple manager is lusty to enjoy the wife of
another devotee.
To do this he might proclaim her husband to be in maya in
order to bring
the woman under his control. This is a most disgraceful
affair and it can
have nasty repercussions. Therefore, before the temple
president decides
if the husband is in maya and he must manage the wife
directly, he should
get the authorization of the GBC or the temple council.
In any case, even
if the manager must deal directly with the wife of
another they should
never speak or meet in a closed place and always there
should be others
around to make sure that no illicit activities take place
or no unwanted
attachments develop. For example, if they are meeting in
the office of the
temple president, the door should be open and another
man, or the temple
president's wife, should be there. Again, if the wife of
the temple
president is available for management services then she
should deal with
that lady directly.
It is important
to note here that although the temple president might
utilize his wife to deal with the other women in the
temple, the wife
should not take this as an opportunity to start to
control the temple. It
is essential that the wife not try to manage the
brahmacaris or other men
as this would create a great disturbance to the temple
atmosphere. The
wife of the temple president should only pass
instructions from her
husband to the other ladies in the temple and should not
try to manage the
temple on her own.
4. Pitfalls in Daily Management
There are many
activities which, if performed, can throw a temple off
the course of expanding the Krishna consciousness
movement. We are meant
to preach and deliver the message of Krishna
consciousness throughout the
world, but sometimes we become sidetracked and diverted
from our real
duties. Therefore we have to be careful to avoid the
following basic
mistakes. These mistakes have been recognized over long
periods of time in
ISKCON. They are not at all obvious. Formerly large
segments of the
movement were engaged in such activities with seemingly great
success, but
the ultimate failure of the temples and their leaders
showed without a
shadow of a doubt that good management means following
strictly the
formulas given to us by Srila Prabhupada.
Of all the
formulas coming from Srila Prabhupada, the one relating to
book distribution and temple economy seems to be the most
practical and
important. Prabhupada often said that the economic basis
of the movement
is the sale of our books. He created the formula that the
temple would
give half of its income to the BBT and the other half
would be used for
temple maintenance. This becomes clear when we understand
that the
temple's will sell the books for at least twice the BBT
price, thus
automatically half of their income goes to the BBT to pay
for the books
and the other half goes to the temple treasury.
Prabhupada wanted this
formula to be followed by all his temples for it was the
means of all
spiritual and material success. Keeping this in mind, we
can discuss some
of the pitfalls in temple management.
4.1 Expansion Beyond One's Means
Expanding the
Krishna consciousness movement is one of our aims. We
want to expand the preaching and temples all over the
world. However, when
an individual temple president decides to expand the temple,
or even a
temple council, often they will expand it far beyond the
capacity of the
temple finances. We have practically seen this occurring
in some parts of
the world.
This is one of
the most serious traps the temple managers can fall
into. If the temple managers are not mature in their
spiritual
realization, they may equate the material opulence of the
temple with
success. They may see that the more opulent the temple
is, the more
successful they are as temple managers. Sometimes a temple
president will
also compete on the subtle platform with other temple
presidents. If
another temple president has got an opulent temple, then
the first temple
president will think that he has got to have one as well.
This will cause
him to want to expand the temple's opulence more and more
to keep pace
with the other temple. Such competition is not on the
transcendental
platform. Real success means increased preaching,
devotees joining, and
books distributed, and not necessarily the increase of
material opulence.
Misconceptions
can cause a temple manager to start to expand the temple
even if he does not have the means to do so. He may buy a
big building at
great expense thus greatly increasing his monthly
operating expenses. He
may take out big loans from the bank with large monthly
payments. And in
order to pay for this, he will have to push the devotees
more and more to
collect large sums of money. This is not the way to
expand the Krishna
consciousness movement.
One should not
get a big facility unless he really requires it. When
there are so many devotees in the temple that there is
hardly any room to
sleep, then one really requires a bigger facility. But if
that is the
case, then one should have enough devotees to collect
sufficiently to pay
for the larger facility. If one buys a big place
unnecessarily, then he
runs the risk of having to maintain a large, opulent, and
empty temple.
Therefore do not expand unless there is a real need to do
so. Every dollar
spent on a mortgage payment may mean many times that in
fewer books to
distribute.
One should have
a temple room large enough to accommodate a reasonable
number of guests. It may not be possible to hold all the
guests who come,
but an attempt should be made to allow as many as
possible to join in the
temple programs.
Not every person
who is becoming Krishna conscious need live in the
temple. For example, householders might be better off
living outside the
temple in a nearby flat. They can come to the temple
every day for the
temple programs and engage in service as they can. If
they are not engaged
in essential service in the temple, where they will then
be maintained by
the temple, they will have to work outside in order to
support their
family. If they are living outside and working they can
perform a valuable
service by donating to the temple some of their monthly
salary for its
support. This is the actual varnasrama principle: the
householders live
outside the temple and give as much as they can for the
support of the
temple's preaching activities and devotees.
In the
Upadesamrta (The Nectar of Instruction) of Srila Rupa Gosami,
there is a verse which states, atyaharah prayasas ca.
Prayasah means to
over endeavor for mundane achievements. This is something
which can
destroy spiritual life. Therefore, striving to expand the
temple when
there are no resources to do so, is one of the
impediments to successful
spiritual life and must be avoided by any responsible
temple leader.
4.2 The Paraphernalia Trap
When the temple
managers have fallen into the trap of overexpansion of
the temple's facilities, they will require some means to
keep the project
functioning. Because they have expanded far beyond the
capacity of the
present devotees to maintain using the traditional
methods of book
distribution, they have to create some other form of
income which will
have a high return for a small effort. This requirement
gave birth to
paraphernalia distribution in ISKCON.
Paraphernalia means
any product which is not books. In the past ISKCON
leaders have induced the devotees to sell paintings,
rugs, tee shirts,
bumper stickers, and so on, to raise the necessary funds
to pay the large
overheads of their temples. Such collection programs
become critical when
brahmacaris are performing such activities as a temple
organized affair.
Some temple presidents justifiably argue that they only
recently became
the president of the temple and that they inherited the
temple with its
large expenses from the previous administration. This may
be true, but it
does not change the point. Although one may be sincere in
his utilization
of paraphernalia, still it means that the temple is
supported in an
artificial manner similar to the methodology of the
materialistic society.
Prabhupada wanted his temples maintained by book
distribution, for this
would be the best way to expand the preaching of the
Krishna consciousness
movement and at the same time it was the safest means of
creating economic
stability. Paraphernalia has gone a long way to ruining
book distribution
in some parts of the world.
Paraphernalia is
seemingly an easy way to make money. Devotees, instead
of having to preach and present themselves as devotees,
could now wander
the streets, offices, and homes, and sell items which
were in demand by
the materialists. Books about God consciousness are hard
to sell since the
people basically do not want such literatures (at least
in the opulent
West) but material goods such as paintings or rugs are in
high demand and
easy to sell. Besides, one can purchase these items
wholesale in Asia and
sell them for many times their original price making a
fantastic profit
without much effort.
Because of the
great success of paraphernalia, temples were becoming
more and more opulent on the basis of material goods.
Temple presidents
saw this as a means to expand their temples more and
more, and even
purchase large buildings which were formerly far beyond
their means. It
seemed that now things would become easy to manage.
However, what
happened was that once starting on this paraphernalia,
one was attached to it, just as one gets addicted to
drugs. Since the
temple was expanded beyond the normal expected facilities
for the number
of devotees, one must continue with the paraphernalia to
pay for the
temple expenses. This meant that the devotees would have
to continue with
the paraphernalia at all costs.
The real problem
with paraphernalia is that it really does not produce
more income to expand the preaching. As the income from
paraphernalia
increases, so do the expenses, and these inflated
overheads cause the net
profit to remain the same. Although one tries to maintain
the program over
longer periods of time, he runs into problems as the
devotees doing
paraphernalia need "vacations" and breaks from
the hard grind of
collecting, which causes breaks in the flow of income.
Sometimes devotees
become exhausted and require extensive breaks. All in
all, the overall
increase in income is negated by the increase in expenses
and decrease in
efficiency of the individual collector.
After some time,
the devotees become spiritually weak. Staying out late
at night to visit people's homes, far away from the
temple association,
wearing karmi clothes and never speaking about Krishna,
the devotees lose
their taste for spiritual life and become contaminated
with material
desires. They gradually give up the essence of spiritual
life, the
preaching mission, and consider that maintenance of their
bodily existence
in their grhastha-asrama (since they all inevitably get
married) is the
goal of spiritual life. Some go away from Krishna
consciousness
completely, never to be seen again. Some take up the same
paraphernalia
business they did in ISKCON but now completely in the
material world.
Others just become useless and retire to an inactive life
in the temple.
The net result
is that book distribution becomes weakened and even
non-existent. The devotees lose all strength to actually
present
themselves as devotees to the public and sell books. Thus
instead of being
a panacea for all economic problems, it turns to be a
great disaster.
After a while one is either forced to change the basic
principles of
Krishna consciousness from preaching to collecting money
to maintain the
temple, or a temple just withers away completely due to
the basic lack of
enthusiasm of the devotees.
Krishna does not
want to send new devotees who are sincere in spiritual
life to places where material economic means dominate the
daily activities
of the temple. Some may still join, but they may be
attracted to
maintaining bodily comforts and material opulence. When
this happens
people come to ISKCON to solve their economic problems.
This is not at all
satisfactory to the proper prosecution of spiritual life.
We want devotees
to join who are eager to develop their love of God and
serve Him through
the sankirtana mission of Lord Caitanya Mahaprabhu. Thus
this
paraphernalia trap has to be avoided by all temple
presidents who are
sincerely interested in prosecuting and preaching
spiritual life.
It is important
to mention here that the paraphernalia trap mentioned
above does not apply to householders working to maintain
their families.
Srila Prabhupada even authorized the starting of an
incense business,
called Spiritual Sky Incense, for the sake of the
householder's
maintenance. They were to work in this business, selling
the incense
wherever they could, and take a sha